Volltextveröffentlichung

• Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte

  R.D. v. POLAND

  Art. 6, Art. 6 Abs. 1, Art. 6 Abs. 3 Buchst. c, Art. 41 MRK
  Violation of Art. 6-1 Violation of Art. 6-3-c Pecuniary damage - claim dismissed Non-pecuniary damage - financial award Costs and expenses award - domestic proceedings Costs and expenses award - Convention proceedings (englisch)

Verfahrensgang

• EKMR, 22.10.1997 - 29692/96
• EGMR, 15.02.2001 - 29692/96
• EGMR, 18.12.2001 - 29692/96, 34612/97

Wird zitiert von ... (10)Neu Zitiert selbst (2)

• EGMR, 26.10.2000 - 30210/96

  Das Recht auf Verfahrensbeschleunigung gemäß Art. 6 Abs. 1 S. 1 EMRK in …

  Auszug aus EGMR, 18.12.2001 - 29692/96

  Applying the criteria laid down in its case law (see, for instance, Kudla v. Poland [GC], no. 30210/96, § 168, ECHR 2000-XI) and making its assessment on an equitable basis, the Court allows the applicant's claim in full, together with any value-added tax that may be chargeable, less 579.31 Euro received by way of legal aid from the Council of Europe.
• EGMR, 25.09.1992 - 13191/87

  PHAM HOANG c. FRANCE

  Auszug aus EGMR, 18.12.2001 - 29692/96

  The first is lack of "sufficient means to pay for legal assistance", the second is that "the interests of justice" must require that such assistance be given free (see, among many other authorities, the Pham Hoang v. France judgment of 25 September 1992, Series A no. 243 p. 23, § 39).

• EGMR, 22.03.2007 - 59519/00

  STAROSZCZYK v. POLAND

  In discharging that obligation, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001).

  In discharging obligation to provide parties to civil proceedings with legal aid, when it is provided by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (Del Sol, R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001).

• EGMR, 05.03.2024 - 60569/09

  LEKA v. ALBANIA

  The first is lack of "sufficient means to pay for legal assistance", the second is that "the interests of justice" must require that such assistance be given free (see Pham Hoang v. France, 25 September 1992, § 39, Series A no. 243; R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 43, 18 December 2001; and Zdravko Stanev v. Bulgaria, no. 32238/04, § 36, 6 November 2012).
• EGMR, 13.09.2011 - 30358/04

  WERSEL v. POLAND

  However, the Court must satisfy itself that the method chosen by the domestic authorities in a particular case is compatible with the Convention (see, mutatis mutandis, in criminal law proceedings, R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001; Kulikowski v. Poland, no. 18353/03, §§ 58 and 59 ECHR 2009-... (extracts); Antonicelli v. Poland, no. 2815/05, §§ 33 and 34, 19 May 2009 and, in civil law proceedings, Tabor v. Poland, no. 12825/02, §§ 39-43, 27 June 2006).

  The Court notes at the outset that the facts of the instant application are similar to those in the case of R.D. v. Poland (see R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, 18 December 2001), in which a violation of Article 6 § 1 read in conjunction with Article 6 § 3 (c) of the Convention was found by the Court.

 
• OLG Stuttgart, 18.03.2010 - 1 Ws 9/10

  Übernahme der Vollstreckung rechtskräftig verhängter Freiheitsstrafen nach …

  In der Rechtsprechung des Europäischen Gerichtshofs für Menschenrechte ( EGMR ) wird das vor dem Hintergrund des übergreifenden Fairnessgebots und des Gebots wirksamer Verteidigung dahin konkretisiert, dass Pflichtverteidigung menschenrechtlich geboten sein kann, wenn die Natur der Vorwürfe die Notwendigkeit mit sich bringt, geeignete Argumente über rechtlich komplexe Fragen zu entwickeln, und/oder wenn das Verfahren derart komplex ist, dass anwaltlicher Beistand geboten erscheint; zu berücksichtigen sind auch die Schwere des Vorwurfs und die drohende Rechtsfolge (s. nur EGMR , Urt. v. 18.12.2001 - 29692/96 and 34612/97 "R. D. ./. Polen" §§ 48 f.;… Meyer-Ladewig, Europäische Menschenrechtskonvention , 2. Aufl. 2006, Art. 6 Rdn. 91 c).
• EGMR, 19.05.2009 - 18353/03

  KULIKOWSKI c. POLOGNE

  En s'acquittant de son obligation d'apporter une aide judiciaire aux parties à la procédure pénale lorsqu'une telle mesure est prévue par le droit interne, l'Etat doit en outre faire preuve de diligence afin d'assurer aux intéressés la jouissance réelle et effective de leurs droits garantis par l'article 6 (R.D. c. Pologne, nos 29692/96 et 34612/97, § 44, 18 décembre 2001).
• EGMR, 15.12.2009 - 2619/05

  ZAPADKA v. POLAND

  In discharging its obligation to provide parties to proceedings with legal aid when it is provided by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (see Del Sol v. France, no. 46800/99, § 21, ECHR 2002-II; Staroszczyk v. Poland, cited above, § 130, Sialkowska v. Poland, cited above, § 107, Smyk v. Poland, no. 8958/04, § 4, 28 July 2009; Arcinski v. Poland, no. 41373/04, § 34, 15 September 2009 and R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001, mutatis mutandis).
• EGMR, 22.03.2007 - 8932/05

  SIALKOWSKA v. POLAND

  In discharging obligation to provide parties to civil proceedings with legal aid, when it is provided by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (Del Sol, R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001).
• EGMR, 19.05.2009 - 2815/05

  ANTONICELLI v. POLAND

  In discharging its obligation to provide parties to criminal proceedings with legal aid, when this is provided for by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (see R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001).
• EGMR, 12.01.2010 - 33539/02

  BAKOWSKA v. POLAND

  In discharging its obligation to provide parties to proceedings with legal aid when it is provided by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (see Del Sol v. France, no. 46800/99, § 21, ECHR 2002-II; Staroszczyk v. Poland, cited above, § 130, Sialkowska v. Poland, cited above, § 107, Smyk v. Poland, no. 8958/04, § 4, 28 July 2009; Arcinski v. Poland, no. 41373/04, § 34, 15 September 2009 and R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001, mutatis mutandis).
• EGMR, 15.09.2009 - 41373/04

  ARCINSKI v. POLAND

  In discharging its obligation to provide parties to criminal proceedings with legal aid, when this is provided for by domestic law, the State must, moreover, display diligence so as to secure to those persons the genuine and effective enjoyment of the rights guaranteed under Article 6 (see R.D. v. Poland, nos. 29692/96 and 34612/97, § 44, 18 December 2001).