Rechtsprechung
| EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09, 67354/09 |
Volltextveröffentlichungen (3)
- Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte
BABAR AHMAD AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
Art. 3, Art. 35 MRK
Remainder inadmissible No violation of Article 3 - Prohibition of torture (Article 3 - Degrading punishment Degrading treatment Inhuman punishment Inhuman treatment Extradition) (United States of America) ... - Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte
BABAR AHMAD AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM - [Deutsche Übersetzung] Zusammenfassung durch das Österreichische Institut für Menschenrechte (ÖIM)
[DEU] Remainder inadmissible;No violation of Article 3 - Prohibition of torture (Article 3 - Degrading punishment;Degrading treatment;Inhuman punishment;Inhuman treatment;Extradition) (the United States of America)
- juris(Abodienst) (Volltext/Leitsatz)
Kurzfassungen/Presse (2)
- RIS Bundeskanzleramt Österreich (Ausführliche Zusammenfassung)
- spiegel.de (Pressebericht, 10.04.2012)
Briten dürfen Hassprediger an USA ausliefern
Besprechungen u.ä.
- skmr.ch (Kurzaufsatz mit Bezug zur Entscheidung)
Die Einzelhaft als Herausforderung für den Freiheitsentzug
In Nachschlagewerken (2)
Sonstiges
- 123recht.net (Meldung mit Bezug zur Entscheidung, 10.07.2012)
Abu Hamza stellt in Straßburg neuen Antrag gegen Auslieferung
Verfahrensgang
- EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
- EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09, 67354/09
- EGMR, 24.09.2012 - 24027/07
Papierfundstellen
- NVwZ 2013, 925
Wird zitiert von ... (25) Neu Zitiert selbst (25)
- EGMR, 08.11.2005 - 64812/01
ALVER v. ESTONIA
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
Article 3 did not require an applicant to show deliberate imposition of pain or deliberate indifference to it (Alver v. Estonia, no. 64812/01, § 55, 8 November 2005; Peers v. Greece, no. 28524/95, §§ 74-75, ECHR 2001-III), whereas this was a specific requirement in order to show a violation of the Eighth Amendment (the subjective test set out in Wilson: see paragraph 105 above).The length of the period during which a person is detained in the particular conditions also has to be considered (see, among other authorities, Ciorap v. Moldova, no. 12066/02, § 64, 19 June 2007; Alver v. Estonia, no. 64812/01, 8 November 2005; Ostrovar v. Moldova, no. 35207/03, § 79, 13 September 2005).
- EGMR, 26.10.2000 - 30210/96
Das Recht auf Verfahrensbeschleunigung gemäß Art. 6 Abs. 1 S. 1 EMRK in …
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
However, the State must ensure that a person is detained under conditions which are compatible with respect for his human dignity, that the manner and method of the execution of the measure do not subject him to distress or hardship exceeding the unavoidable level of suffering inherent in detention and that, given the practical demands of imprisonment, his health and well-being are adequately secured (see Kudla v. Poland [GC], no. 30210/96, §§ 92-94158, ECHR-XI, and Cenbauer v. Croatia, no. 73786/01, § 44, ECHR 2006-III; A.B. v. Russia, cited above, § 100). - EGMR, 08.07.2004 - 48787/99
Transnistrien
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
- that the measure may have been calculated to break the applicant's resistance or will (ibid, § 167; Ilascu and Others v. Moldova and Russia [GC], no. 48787/99, § 446, ECHR 2004-VII);.
- EGMR, 28.07.1999 - 25803/94
Zur "Einzelfallprüfung" und "geltungszeitlichen Interpretation" im Rahmen des …
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
It is correct that the Court has always distinguished between torture on the one hand and inhuman or degrading punishment on the other (see, for instance, Ireland v. the United Kingdom, 18 January 1978, § 167, Series A no. 25; Selmouni v. France [GC], no. 25803/94, §§ 95-106, ECHR 1999-V). - EGMR, 06.04.2000 - 26772/95
LABITA c. ITALIE
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
It prohibits in absolute terms torture or inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment, irrespective of the circumstances and the victim's behaviour (see, among other authorities, Labita v. Italy [GC], no 26772/95, § 119, ECHR 2000-IV; A.B. v. Russia, no. 1439/06, § 99, 14 October 2010). - EGMR, 04.12.2007 - 44362/04
DICKSON c. ROYAUME-UNI
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
Where there are limitations on the services provided, for example restrictions on group prayer, these are necessary and inevitable consequences of imprisonment (see, mutatis mutandis, Dickson v. the United Kingdom [GC], no. 44362/04, § 68, ECHR 2007-V). - EGMR, 30.03.2009 - 19324/02
Léger ./. Frankreich
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
The Government relied on the Court's rulings in Kafkaris and Léger v. France, no. 19324/02, ECHR 2006-..., and the United Kingdom court's rulings in Wellington and Bieber (see paragraphs 64-72 and 144 above). - EGMR, 18.01.2017 - 41576/98
GANCI ET 12 AUTRES AFFAIRES CONTRE L'ITALIE
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
At the same time, however, the Court has found that the prohibition of contact with other prisoners for security, disciplinary or protective reasons does not in itself amount to inhuman treatment or punishment (see Messina v. Italy (no. 2) (dec.), no. 25498/94, ECHR 1999-V, quoted with approval by the Grand Chamber in Ramirez Sanchez v. France, cited above, § 12; Öcalan v. Turkey [GC], no. 46221/99, § 191, ECHR 2005-IV). - EGMR, 19.06.2007 - 12066/02
CIORAP v. MOLDOVA
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
The length of the period during which a person is detained in the particular conditions also has to be considered (see, among other authorities, Ciorap v. Moldova, no. 12066/02, § 64, 19 June 2007; Alver v. Estonia, no. 64812/01, 8 November 2005; Ostrovar v. Moldova, no. 35207/03, § 79, 13 September 2005). - EGMR, 29.11.2007 - 9852/03
HUMMATOV v. AZERBAIJAN
Auszug aus EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
9852/03 and 13413/04, § 121, 29 November 2007); the United States courts did not even consider a significant deterioration of a detainee's mental condition to be sufficient for an Eighth Amendment violation unless there was also a deprivation of basic physical needs such as food, shelter, clothing or warmth (see Hill and Magluta, cited at paragraph 110 above). - EGMR, 09.03.2006 - 73786/01
CENBAUER v. CROATIA
- EGMR, 03.07.2001 - 44190/98
NIVETTE contre la FRANCE
- EGMR, 10.08.2006 - 24668/03
OLAECHEA CAHUAS v. SPAIN
- EGMR, 20.01.2016 - 25196/94
IWÁNCZUK CONTRE LA POLOGNE
- EGMR, 11.03.2004 - 42346/98
G.B. v. BULGARIA
- EGMR, 15.03.2018 - 12066/02
CIORAP CONTRE LA RÉPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA ET 26 AUTRES AFFAIRES
- EGMR, 22.06.2006 - 24245/03
D. ET AUTRES c. TURQUIE
- EGMR, 09.05.2006 - 26844/04
SALEM c. PORTUGAL
- EGMR, 18.09.2006 - 22871/06
SAOUDI c. ESPAGNE
- EGMR, 22.09.2009 - 1273/06
MADONIA c. ITALIE
- EGMR, 07.07.1989 - 14038/88
Jens Söring
- BVerfG, 16.01.2010 - 2 BvR 2299/09
Unzulässige Auslieferung an die Türkei (Staatsschutzdelikte; "erschwerte" …
- EGMR, 12.02.2008 - 21906/04
KAFKARIS c. CHYPRE
- EGMR, 11.12.2003 - 39084/97
YANKOV c. BULGARIE
- EGMR, 27.11.2003 - 65436/01
HENAF c. FRANCE
- EGMR, 13.12.2012 - 39630/09
El Masri klagt gegen Mazedonien
Quatrièmement, l'Etat défendeur ne demanda aux autorités américaines aucune assurance propre à éviter au requérant le risque de subir des mauvais traitements (voir, a contrario, Mamatkoulov et Askarov, précité, §§ 71-78, Al-Moayad, décision précitée, et Babar Ahmad et autres c. Royaume-Uni (déc.), nos 24027/07, 11949/08 et 36742/08, § 113, 6 juillet 2010). - EGMR, 04.09.2014 - 140/10
Belgien wegen Auslieferung von Ex-Fußballprofi verurteilt
Il déduisait de celui-ci que la Cour jugeait désormais que le caractère compressible ou non d'une peine d'emprisonnement perpétuelle devait faire l'objet d'un contrôle préventif, avant même que le détenu ne commence à purger sa peine et donc que la distinction opérée dans l'arrêt Babar Ahmad et autres c. Royaume-Uni, (nos 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09 et 67354/09, 10 avril 2012) selon que la personne faisant l'objet d'une extradition ait été condamnée ou non n'était plus pertinente.[1] Babar Ahmad et autres c. Royaume-Uni, nos 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09 et 67354/09, § 177, 10 avril 2012.
- EGMR, 24.07.2014 - 28761/11
Polen zahlt Schmerzensgeld für Haft in CIA-Gefängnis
- BVerfG, 04.05.2018 - 2 BvR 632/18
Erfolglose Verfassungsbeschwerde gegen Ausweisung nach Tunesien
(4) Der Europäische Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte hat die Bedeutung der fortgeltenden Strafzwecke (…vgl. EGMR, Urteile vom 17. Januar 2012 - 9146/07 et al. -, Harkins und Edwards/Großbritannien, Rn. 137 f.; vom 10. April 2012 - 24027/07 et al. -, Babar Ahmad/Großbritannien, Rn. 241 f.;… vom 4. September 2014 - 140/10 -, Trabelsi/Belgien, Rn. 124 …und vom 17. Januar 2017 - 57592/08 -, Hutchinson/Großbritannien, Rn. 42) und die Menschenwürde (…vgl. EGMR, Urteile vom 9. Juli 2013 - 66069/09 et al. -, Vinter/Großbritannien, Rn. 113 …und vom 26. April 2016 - 10511/10 -, Murray/Niederlande, Rn. 101) als wesentliche, bei der von Art. 3 EMRK geforderten Überprüfung einer lebenslangen Freiheitsstrafe zu berücksichtigende Kriterien hervorgehoben. - EGMR, 24.07.2014 - 7511/13
Polen zahlt Schmerzensgeld für Haft in CIA-Gefängnis
- EGMR, 29.04.2014 - 9043/05
NATSVLISHVILI AND TOGONIDZE v. GEORGIA
24027/07, 11949/08 and 36742/08, ECHR 6 July 2010). - EGMR, 31.05.2018 - 33234/12
Litauen und Rumänien mitverantwortlich für CIA-Folter
24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09 and 67354/09, § 168, 10 April 2012; El-Masri, cited above, §§ 212-214, with further references; Al Nashiri v. Poland, cited above, § 454; Husayn (Abu Zubaydah) v. Poland, cited above, § 450; and Nasr and Ghali, cited above, § 242). - VG Karlsruhe, 13.09.2022 - A 5 K 7903/18
Vereinigte Staaten: Subsidiärer Schutz bei konkret drohender unverhältnismäßiger …
In Ausnahmefällen kann jedoch eine grob unverhältnismä ßige Haftstrafe eine Art. 3 EMRK verletzende Misshandlung darstellen (EGMR, Urteil vom 10.04.2012, Barbar Ahmad - 24027/07 NVwZ 2013, 925, Rn. 238).24027/07-, NVwZ 2013, 925, Rn. 239).
- EGMR, 07.06.2016 - 20672/15
FINDIKOGLU v. GERMANY
32.Der Gerichtshof fügt hinzu, dass er - außer in Fällen im Zusammenhang mit der Todesstrafe - höchst selten eine Verletzung von Artikel 3 festgestellt hat, wenn es um die Abschiebung eines Beschwerdeführers in einen Staat mit einer langen Tradition der Achtung der Demokratie, Menschenrechte und Rechtsstaatlichkeit ging (siehe Babar Ahmad u. a../. das Vereinigte Königreich, Individualbeschwerden Nrn. 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09 und 67354/09, Rdnr. 179, 10. April 2012). - EGMR, 29.05.2018 - 48852/17
HANSEN v. NORWAY
24027/07 and 4 others, 10 April 2012; Van der Ven v. the Netherlands, no. 50901/99, ECHR 2003-II; and Ramirez Sanchez v. France [GC], no. 59450/00, ECHR 2006-IX.It had been established that all measures implemented in connection with the applicant's conditions of confinement had been authorised by or implemented pursuant to law, and they had been based on what the European Court of Human Rights had referred to as "genuine grounds both ab initio as well as when its duration is extended" (see Babar Ahmad and Others v. the United Kingdom, nos. 24027/07 and 4 others, § 212, 10 April 2012).
- EGMR, 20.10.2011 - 29090/06
Vereinbarkeit einer Verfahrensdauer von fast 4 Jahren bei Durchlaufen von 3 …
- VG Ansbach, 06.10.2020 - AN 17 K 17.33251
Erfolglose Asylklage jordanischer Staatsangehöriger
- VG Berlin, 13.02.2020 - 29 K 92.17
- EGMR, 20.06.2013 - 63638/09
TURLUYEVA v. RUSSIA
- EGMR, 10.05.2011 - 48059/06
DIMITROV AND HAMANOV v. BULGARIA
- EGMR, 04.04.2019 - 36538/17
G.S. v. BULGARIA
- EGMR, 09.11.2023 - 49134/20
LANG v. UKRAINE
- EGMR, 12.12.2017 - 30614/15
LÓPEZ ELORZA v. SPAIN
- VG München, 15.12.2016 - M 2 S 16.35183
Anordnung der Abschiebung in den Senegal
- EGMR, 07.12.2017 - 43999/16
- EGMR, 12.05.2016 - 62235/09
GAYSANOVA v. RUSSIA
- EGMR, 07.10.2014 - 31283/11
S.R. c. FRANCE
- VG München, 29.09.2015 - M 2 K 14.31128
Kein Anspruch auf Zuerkennung der Flüchtlingseigenschaft eines iranischen …
- EGMR, 27.11.2012 - 3325/10
RUSHING v. THE NETHERLANDS
- EGMR, 20.11.2012 - 20696/12
KULEVSKIY v. RUSSIA
Rechtsprechung
| EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08 |
Volltextveröffentlichung
Verfahrensgang
- EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08
- EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 24027/07
- EGMR, 24.09.2012 - 24027/07
Wird zitiert von ... (0) Neu Zitiert selbst (13)
- EGMR, 07.07.1989 - 14038/88
Jens Söring
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
Lord Hoffmann, Baroness Hale and Lord Carswell found that, on the basis of Soering v. the United Kingdom, 7 July 1989, § 89, Series A no. 161, Article 3, insofar as it applied to inhuman and degrading treatment and not to torture, was applicable only in attenuated form to extradition cases.Lord Hoffmann, giving the lead speech, considered the Court's judgment Chahal v. the United Kingdom, 15 November 1996, § 81, Reports of Judgments and Decisions 1996-V. There, the Court stated that it should not be inferred from its remarks in Soering v. the United Kingdom, 7 July 1989, § 89, Series A no. 161 that there was "any room for balancing the risk of ill-treatment against the reasons for expulsion in determining whether a State's responsibility under Article 3 (art. 3) is engaged." Lord Hoffmann stated:.
46827/99 and 46951/99, §§ 90 and 91, ECHR 2005-I, the Grand Chamber confirmed the principle first laid down in Soering v. the United Kingdom, 7 July 1989, § 113, Series A no. 161, that an issue might exceptionally be raised under Article 6 by an extradition decision in circumstances where the fugitive had suffered or risked suffering a flagrant denial of a fair trial in the requesting country.
- EGMR, 03.04.2001 - 27229/95
KEENAN v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
The Court has frequently found that Article 3 is relative and depends on all the circumstances of a case (see, for example, Keenan v. the United Kingdom, no. 27229/95, §§ 108 and 115, ECHR 2001-III). - EGMR, 10.02.1995 - 15175/89
ALLENET DE RIBEMONT c. FRANCE
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
Although the press release does go further than merely announcing the decision to freeze the fourth applicant's assets, and thus it may be said to lack the necessary discretion and circumspection required by Allenet de Ribemont v. France, judgment of 10 February 1995, Series A no. 308, § 38, some comment on a matter of such public interest is inevitable.
- EGMR, 19.04.2001 - 28524/95
PEERS v. GREECE
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
The conditions were analogous to, if not worse than, those found to be in violation of Article 3 in G.B. v. Bulgaria, no. 42346/98, 11 March 2004 and Peers v. Greece, no. 28524/95, ECHR 2001-III. For instance, in G.B., the applicant was subjected to a stringent custodial regime for more than eight years, which involved twenty-three hours in his cell where he had to take all his meals; in Peers, despite the conditions of his cell, the applicant had at least been allowed to have his cell door open during the day. - EGMR, 28.06.2007 - 36549/03
Recht auf ein faires Strafverfahren (Beweisverwertungsverbot; Verwertungsverbot …
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
Moreover, this Court's judgments in Jalloh v. Germany [GC], no. 54810/00, ECHR 2006-... and Harutyunyan v. Armenia, no. 36549/03, ECHR 2007-... did not assist the fourth applicant. - EGMR, 10.07.2001 - 33394/96
PRICE v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
For example, in Price v. the United Kingdom, no. 33394/96, ECHR 2001-VII a four-limb-deficient thalidomide victim with numerous heath problems was detained for three nights and four days. - EGMR, 04.02.2003 - 50901/99
VAN DER VEN v. THE NETHERLANDS
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
In respect of the requirement at ADX Florence for a prisoner to be strip-searched every time he went for recreation, the applicants observed that similar searches had been found to be in violation of Article 3 in Van der Ven v. the Netherlands, no. 50901/99, ECHR 2003-II and Lorsé and Others v. the Netherlands, no. 52750/99, 4 February 2003. - EGMR, 29.05.2001 - 63716/00
SAWONIUK contre le ROYAUME-UNI
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
In addition, the Court has never found that a trial in a Convention State was unfair simply because of the delay in bringing the prosecution (see for example, Sawoniuk v. the United Kingdom (dec.), no. 63716/00, ECHR 2001-VI where the applicant was tried for war crimes committed forty-four years earlier). - EGMR, 04.02.2003 - 52750/99
LORSE AND OTHERS v. THE NETHERLANDS
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
In respect of the requirement at ADX Florence for a prisoner to be strip-searched every time he went for recreation, the applicants observed that similar searches had been found to be in violation of Article 3 in Van der Ven v. the Netherlands, no. 50901/99, ECHR 2003-II and Lorsé and Others v. the Netherlands, no. 52750/99, 4 February 2003. - EGMR, 11.03.2004 - 42346/98
G.B. v. BULGARIA
Auszug aus EGMR, 06.07.2010 - 24027/07
The conditions were analogous to, if not worse than, those found to be in violation of Article 3 in G.B. v. Bulgaria, no. 42346/98, 11 March 2004 and Peers v. Greece, no. 28524/95, ECHR 2001-III. For instance, in G.B., the applicant was subjected to a stringent custodial regime for more than eight years, which involved twenty-three hours in his cell where he had to take all his meals; in Peers, despite the conditions of his cell, the applicant had at least been allowed to have his cell door open during the day. - EGMR, 11.07.2006 - 59638/00
BASTONE c. ITALIE
- EGMR, 10.11.2005 - 56317/00
ARGENTI c. ITALIE
- EGMR, 12.02.2008 - 21906/04
KAFKARIS c. CHYPRE
Rechtsprechung
| EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 11949/08 |
Kurzfassungen/Presse
- RIS Bundeskanzleramt Österreich (Ausführliche Zusammenfassung)
Sonstiges
- Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte (Verfahrensmitteilung)
[ENG]
Wird zitiert von ... (5)
- EGMR, 13.12.2012 - 39630/09
El Masri klagt gegen Mazedonien
Quatrièmement, l'Etat défendeur ne demanda aux autorités américaines aucune assurance propre à éviter au requérant le risque de subir des mauvais traitements (voir, a contrario, Mamatkoulov et Askarov, précité, §§ 71-78, Al-Moayad, décision précitée, et Babar Ahmad et autres c. Royaume-Uni (déc.), nos 24027/07, 11949/08 et 36742/08, § 113, 6 juillet 2010). - EGMR, 24.07.2014 - 7511/13
Polen zahlt Schmerzensgeld für Haft in CIA-Gefängnis
- VG Berlin, 13.02.2020 - 29 K 92.17 Aber selbst wenn dem Kläger die Vollstreckung der dreimonatigen Haftstrafe drohen würde, ist nicht beachtlich wahrscheinlich, dass ihn konkret in den irakischen Haftanstalten und Gefängnissen Bedingungen erwarten, die unzumutbar im Sinne von Art. 3 EMRK sind (ebenso: VG Bayreuth…, Urteil vom 12. Oktober 2017 - B 3 K 17.31455, juris, Rn. 63; zu den Anforderungen vgl. EGMR, Urteil vom 10. April 2012 - 24027/07, 11949/08, 36742/08, 66911/09, 67354/09 (Babar Ahmad u. a./Vereinigtes Königreich), NVwZ 2013, 925, 930 [Rn. 237];… Marx, Kommentar zum AsylG, 10. Auflage 2019, § 4 Rn. 33).
- EGMR, 09.11.2023 - 49134/20
LANG v. UKRAINE
- EGMR, 12.05.2016 - 62235/09
GAYSANOVA v. RUSSIA