Volltextveröffentlichung

• Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte

  J.A. AND OTHERS v. ITALY

  Preliminary objection joined to merits and dismissed (Art. 34) Individual applications;(Art. 34) Victim;Violation of Article 3 - Prohibition of torture (Article 3 - Degrading treatment;Inhuman treatment) (Substantive aspect);Violation of Article 5+5-2 - Right to ...

Sonstiges

• Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte (Verfahrensmitteilung)

  J.A. AND OTHERS v. ITALY

  Art. 1, Art. 1, Art. 5 Abs. 1, Art. 5 Abs. 1, Art. 5 Abs. 1, Art. 11, Art. 14Protokoll Nr. 4 Art. 2Protokoll Nr. 4 Art. 2 Abs. 1Protokoll Nr. 4 Art. 4 MRK
  [ENG]

Wird zitiert von ... (8)Neu Zitiert selbst (6)

• EuGH, 15.03.2017 - C-528/15

  Al Chodor - Vorlage zur Vorabentscheidung - Kriterien und Verfahren zur …

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  Thus, if the execution of a measure depriving a person of liberty is to be consistent with the objective of protecting the individual from arbitrariness, that means, in particular, that there can be no element of bad faith or deception on the part of the authorities (judgments of 15 March 2017, Al Chodor, C-528/15, EU:C:2017:213, paragraph 39, and of 12 February 2019, TC, C-492/18 PPU, EU:C:2019:108, paragraph 59).

  It follows from the foregoing that the detention of a third-country national who is subject to a removal procedure, constituting a serious interference with his or her right to liberty, is subject to compliance with strict safeguards, namely the presence of a legal basis, clarity, predictability, accessibility and protection against arbitrariness (judgment of 15 March 2017, Al Chodor, C-528/15, EU:C:2017:213, paragraph 40).

• EGMR, 17.07.2014 - 47848/08

  CENTRE FOR LEGAL RESOURCES ON BEHALF OF VALENTIN CÂMPEANU v. ROMANIA

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  It thus considers that there is no need to pursue the examination of the applicants' remaining complaints (see Centre for Legal Resources on behalf of Valentin Câmpeanu v. Romania [GC], no. 47848/08, § 156, ECHR 2014; see also Khlaifia and Others, cited above, §§ 248-54).
• EGMR, 25.01.2018 - 22696/16

  J.R. ET AUTRES c. GRÈCE

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  In this context, the Court also reiterates its well-established case-law to the effect that, having regard to the absolute character of Article 3, the difficulties deriving from the increased inflow of migrants and asylum-seekers, in particular for States which form the external borders of the European Union, does not exonerate member States of the Council of Europe from their obligations under this provision (see M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece, cited above, § 223; Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy [GC], no. 27765/09, § 122, ECHR 2012; Khlaifia and Others, cited above, § 184; and J.R. and Others v. Greece, no. 22696/16, § 137, 25 January 2018).

 
• EGMR, 14.01.2021 - 73700/13

  E.K. c. GRÈCE

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  The Court's assessment 58. The general principles applicable to the treatment of people held in immigration detention are set out in detail in M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece ([GC], no. 30696/09, §§ 216-22, ECHR 2011), Tarakhel v. Switzerland ([GC], no. 29217/12, §§ 93-99, ECHR 2014 (extracts)) and Khlaifia and Others v. Italy ([GC], no. 16483/12, §§ 158-69, 15 December 2016; see also E.K. v. Greece, no. 73700/13, §§ 72-84, 14 January 2021).
• EuGH, 12.02.2019 - C-492/18

  TC - Vorlage zur Vorabentscheidung - Justizielle Zusammenarbeit in Strafsachen - …

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  Thus, if the execution of a measure depriving a person of liberty is to be consistent with the objective of protecting the individual from arbitrariness, that means, in particular, that there can be no element of bad faith or deception on the part of the authorities (judgments of 15 March 2017, Al Chodor, C-528/15, EU:C:2017:213, paragraph 39, and of 12 February 2019, TC, C-492/18 PPU, EU:C:2019:108, paragraph 59).
• EuGH, 06.10.2022 - C-241/21

  Politsei- ja Piirivalveamet (Placement en rétention - Risque de commettre une …

  Auszug aus EGMR, 30.03.2023 - 21329/18

  Judgment of the Court of Justice of the European Union of 6 October 2022 Politsei- ja Piirivalveamet (placement in detention - risk of committing a criminal offence), ECLI:EU:C:2022:753 28. The relevant parts of this judgment, delivered pursuant to a request for a preliminary ruling from the Riigikohus (the Supreme Court of Estonia) lodged on 14 April 2021 concerning the interpretation of Article 15 § 1 of Directive 2008/115/EC, read as follows:.

• EGMR, 14.12.2023 - 44408/18

  M.M. c. GRÈCE

  Les principes généraux concernant la privation de liberté des demandeurs d'asile dans les centres d'accueil, d'identification et d'enregistrement, ont été rappelés dans les affaires Chahal c. Royaume-Uni, 15 novembre 1996, § 73, Recueil 1996-V, J.R. et autres c. Grèce (no 22696/16, §§ 83-84 et 108-110, 25 janvier 2018) et J.A. et autres c. Italie, no 21329/18, §§ 79-83, 30 mars 2023).
• EGMR, 30.11.2023 - 2080/19

  D.S. c. GRÈCE

  En ce qui concerne les principes généraux relatifs à l'application de l'article 5 § 1 de la Convention dans des affaires soulevant des questions similaires à celles posées par la présente, la Cour renvoie à sa jurisprudence pertinente en la matière Saadi c. Royaume-Uni [GC], no 13229/03, §§ 64 et 74, CEDH 2008, Chahal c. Royaume-Uni, 15 novembre 1996, § 73, Recueil 1996-V, Barjamaj c. Grèce, no 36657/11, §§ 36-38, 2 mai 2013 et J.A. et autres c. Italie, no 21329/18, §§ 79-83, 30 mars 2023).
• EGMR, 23.11.2023 - 47287/17

  A.T. AND OTHERS v. ITALY

  The general principles concerning the conditions of accommodation in hotspots have been summarised in J.A. and Others v. Italy (no. 21329/18, §§ 58 and 65, 30 June 2023).

 
• EGMR, 16.11.2023 - 18911/17

  A.E. AND T.B. v. ITALY

  The Court also refers to Khlaifia and Others, cited above, §§ 88-92) and J.A. and Others v. Italy (no. 21329/18, §§ 79-83, 30 March 2023), the latter concerning, in particular, the restriction of liberty involved in migrants' stays in hotspots.
• EGMR, 19.10.2023 - 13755/18

  A.B. v. ITALY

  The parties' observations in respect of this complaint are similar to those presented in J.A. and Others v. Italy (no. 21329/18, 30 June 2023).
• EGMR, 19.10.2023 - 20860/20

  A.S. v. ITALY

  In the light of the above, as well as of its conclusions in J.A. and Others v. Italy (no. 21329/18, 30 March 2023), the Court dismisses the Government's objection as to the applicant's alleged lack of victim status and concludes that the applicant was subjected to inhuman and degrading treatment during his stay in the hotspot at Lampedusa, in violation of Article 3 of the Convention.
• EGMR, 19.10.2023 - 13110/18

  M.A. v. ITALY

  The parties' observations in respect of this complaint are similar to those presented in J.A. and Others v. Italy (no. 21329/18, 30 June 2023).
• EGMR - 41645/23 (anhängig)

  H.D. v. ITALY

  Has the applicant been subjected to inhuman or degrading treatment in breach of Article 3 of the Convention, during his retention at the "Sant'Anna C.A.R.A. Regional Hub" of Isola di Capo Rizzuto (Crotone), due to the conditions of his stay, taking into account also his vulnerable situation of unaccompanied minor (see, among many others, M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece [GC], no. 30696/09, §§ 216-223, ECHR 2011; J.A. and Others v. Italy, no. 21329/18, §§ 58 and 65, 30 March 2023 and, as to conditions of accommodation in respect of minors, Darboe and Camara v. Italy, no. 5797/17, §§ 167-173, 21 July 2022 and M.A. v. Italy, no. 70583/17, §§ 37-38, 31 August 2023)?.