Volltextveröffentlichungen (2)

• Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte

  KHASHIYEV AND AKAYEVA v. RUSSIA

  Art. 2, Art. 2 Abs. 1, Art. 2 Abs. 2, Art. 3, Art. 13, Art. 35, Art. 35 Abs. 1, Art. 38, Art. 41 MRK
  Preliminary objection rejected (non-exhaustion of domestic remedies) Violations of Art. 2 No violation of Art. 3 (torture) Violation of Art. 3 (failure to investigate) Violation of Art. 13 Non-pecuniary damage - financial awards Costs and expenses partial award - ...

• Europäischer Gerichtshof für Menschenrechte

  KHACHIEV ET AKAIEVA c. RUSSIE

  Art. 2, Art. 2 Abs. 1, Art. 2 Abs. 2, Art. 3, Art. 13, Art. 35, Art. 35 Abs. 1, Art. 38, Art. 41 MRK
  Exception préliminaire rejetée (non-épuisement des voies de recours internes) Violations de l'art. 2 Non-violation de l'art. 3 (torture) Violation de l'art. 3 (absence d'enquête) Violation de l'art. 13 Préjudice moral - réparation pécuniaire Remboursement ...

Kurzfassungen/Presse

• RIS Bundeskanzleramt Österreich (Ausführliche Zusammenfassung)

Verfahrensgang

• EGMR, 19.12.2002 - 57942/00
• EGMR, 24.02.2005 - 57942/00, 57945/00
• EGMR, 02.12.2011 - 57942/00
• EGMR, 12.03.2015 - 57942/00

Wird zitiert von ... (192)

alle Zitatstellen anzeigen
• EGMR, 12.04.2005 - 36378/02

  CHAMAÏEV ET AUTRES c. GEORGIE ET RUSSIE

  57942/00 and 57945/00, 19 December 2002).
• EGMR, 28.02.2012 - 31682/07

  [ENG]

  For a summary of the relevant domestic law provisions see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia (nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 79-98, 24 February 2005).

  The Court reiterates that in circumstances where, as here, a criminal investigation into the killing of an applicant's relative has been ineffective and the effectiveness of any other remedy that might have existed has consequently been undermined, a State will be found to have failed in its obligation under Article 13 of the Convention (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 183, 24 February 2005).

• EGMR, 10.01.2008 - 67797/01

  ZUBAYRAYEV v. RUSSIA

  The civil courts are unable to conduct an independent investigation and are incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults, still less to establish their responsibility (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 119-121, 24 February 2005).

  The Court has found the Russian State authorities responsible for extra-judicial executions or disappearances of civilians in Chechnya in a number of cases, even in the absence of final conclusions from the domestic investigation (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, 24 February 2005; Luluyev and Others v. Russia, no. 69480/01, ECHR 2006-... (extracts); Estamirov and Others v. Russia, no. 60272/00, 12 October 2006; Imakayeva v. Russia, no. 7615/02, ECHR 2006-... (extracts); and Baysayeva v. Russia, no. 74237/01, 5 April 2007).

• EGMR, 03.10.2013 - 2215/05

  ARAPKHANOVY v. RUSSIA

  A civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults or disappearances, still less of establishing their responsibility (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-21, 24 February 2005, and Estamirov and Others v. Russia, no. 60272/00, § 77, 12 October 2006).

  The Court reiterates that in circumstances where a criminal investigation of a killing and infliction of bodily injuries has been ineffective and the effectiveness of any other remedy that might have existed has consequently been undermined, the State will be found to have failed in its obligation under Article 13 of the Convention (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 183, 24 February 2005).

• EGMR, 29.04.2008 - 7653/02

  KAPLANOVA v. RUSSIA

  The Court has already found in a number of similar cases that a civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings as to the perpetrators of fatal assaults, still less of establishing their responsibility (see, among other authorities, Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-121, 24 February 2005).

  In this respect the Government relied on the case of Khashiyev v. Russia in which the applicant had sought and obtained compensation for the death of his relatives (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, 24 February 2002).

• EGMR, 29.03.2011 - 11564/07

  [ENG]

  A civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults or disappearances, still less of establishing their responsibility (see, among many other authorities, Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-121, 24 February 2005).

  The Court reiterates that in circumstances where, as here, a criminal investigation into a disappearance and ill-treatment has been ineffective and the effectiveness of any other remedy that might have existed, including civil remedies suggested by the Government, has consequently been undermined, the State has failed in its obligation under Article 13 of the Convention (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 183, 24 February 2005).

• EGMR, 16.12.2010 - 11528/07

  [ENG]

  A civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults or disappearances, still less of establishing their responsibility (see, among many other authorities, Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-21, 24 February 2005).

  The Court reiterates that in circumstances where, as here, a criminal investigation into a disappearance and ill-treatment has been ineffective and the effectiveness of any other remedy that might have existed, including civil remedies suggested by the Government, has consequently been undermined, the State has failed in its obligation under Article 13 of the Convention (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 183, 24 February 2005).

• EGMR, 23.04.2009 - 3179/05

  GAKIYEV AND GAKIYEVA v. RUSSIA

  A civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults or disappearances, still less of establishing their responsibility (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-21, 24 February 2005).

  The Court further reiterates that the requirements of Article 13 are broader than a Contracting State's obligation under Article 2 to conduct an effective investigation (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, § 183, 24 February 2005).

• EGMR, 29.11.2007 - 57935/00

  TANGIYEVA v. RUSSIA

  A civil court is unable to pursue any independent investigation and is incapable, without the benefit of the conclusions of a criminal investigation, of making any meaningful findings regarding the identity of the perpetrators of fatal assaults, still less of establishing their responsibility (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 119-121, 24 February 2005, and Estamirov and Others, cited above, § 77).

  No photographs were taken and no detailed description of the bodies was recorded before burial, nor did the applicant apply to a domestic court in order to establish the facts and circumstances of her relatives" deaths (see, by contrast, Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, judgment of 24 February 2005, §§ 28-30 and §§ 39-42, and Estamirov and Others v. Russia, no. 60272/00, judgment of 12 October 2006, §§ 18, 20 and 21).

• EGMR, 27.07.2006 - 69481/01

  BAZORKINA v. RUSSIA

  They also referred to the case of Khashiyev v. Russia (see Khashiyev and Akayeva v. Russia, nos. 57942/00 and 57945/00, §§ 39-42, 24 February 2005), where the applicant had received substantial amounts in pecuniary and nonpecuniary damage from the State treasury for the deaths of his relatives in circumstances where there was strong evidence to conclude that the killings had been committed by federal servicemen.
• EGMR, 15.11.2007 - 72118/01

  KHAMIDOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 16.04.2015 - 44297/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 26.11.2009 - 33947/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 07.11.2013 - 40799/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 12.10.2006 - 60272/00

  ESTAMIROV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 29.10.2009 - 43398/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 31.07.2014 - 1774/11

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 05.07.2007 - 68007/01

  ALIKHADZHIYEVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 05.04.2007 - 74237/01

  BAYSAYEVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 09.05.2018 - 52273/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 02.12.2010 - 27065/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 20.06.2013 - 63638/09

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 09.06.2015 - 26562/07

  TAGAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 16.02.2012 - 23944/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 29.03.2011 - 23445/03

  ESMUKHAMBETOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 13.07.2010 - 72250/01

  LOPATA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 01.07.2010 - 17674/02

  DAVYDOV AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE
• EGMR, 22.11.2016 - 3340/08

  ORTSUYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 26.03.2015 - 40166/07

  Russland muss Tschetschenen Schmerzensgeld zahlen
• EGMR, 17.10.2013 - 26824/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 20.03.2008 - 77626/01

  AZIYEVY v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 24.10.2013 - 7821/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 15.03.2011 - 39358/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 31.03.2020 - 51933/08

  MURDALOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA and 2 othe applications
• EGMR, 21.01.2020 - 36963/09

  SAIDOVA v. RUSSIA and 7 other applications
• EGMR, 15.01.2015 - 14705/09

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 24.01.2012 - 24893/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 23.11.2010 - 2858/07

  [FRE]
• EGMR, 24.06.2008 - 44587/98

  ISAAK v. TURKEY
• EGMR, 29.05.2008 - 29133/03

  UTSAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 02.04.2015 - 21135/09

  IREZIYEVY v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 18.09.2014 - 37287/09

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 30.01.2014 - 39436/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 18.04.2013 - 54765/09

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 31.05.2011 - 1721/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 06.02.2007 - 21387/05

  BANKS AND OTHERS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM
• EGMR, 28.04.2015 - 54999/10

  MILIC ET NIKEZIC c. MONTÉNÉGRO
• EGMR, 09.04.2013 - 20562/07

  [FRE]
• EGMR, 05.10.2010 - 4390/03

  [FRE]
• EGMR, 17.06.2010 - 26974/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 23.04.2009 - 4571/04

  ISRAILOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 24.09.2019 - 44776/09

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 09.02.2016 - 21126/09

  NAZYROVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 26.03.2015 - 11237/10

  Russland muss Tschetschenen Schmerzensgeld zahlen
• EGMR, 31.10.2013 - 26960/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 02.09.2010 - 71420/01

  BEKIRSKI v. BULGARIA
• EGMR, 17.06.2010 - 11354/05

  BATAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 11.06.2009 - 33264/04

  KHALITOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 06.11.2008 - 10796/04

  SHAIPOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 23.04.2015 - 30237/10

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 28.02.2012 - 14662/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 03.11.2011 - 24885/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 14.06.2011 - 20303/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 07.06.2011 - 27441/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 18.06.2009 - 20198/05

  MOLLAZEINAL v. CYPRUS
• EGMR, 12.03.2009 - 21816/03

  ELSIYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 27.03.2008 - 21810/03

  TAYSUMOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 23.04.2015 - 36367/09

  KAGIROV c. RUSSIE
• EGMR, 10.10.2013 - 34541/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 29.05.2012 - 36150/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 27.03.2012 - 5432/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.12.2010 - 36542/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 27.05.2010 - 16622/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 28.05.2009 - 13862/05

  KHUMAYDOV AND KHUMAYDOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 08.01.2009 - 20583/04

  ZAKRIYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 27.11.2014 - 2721/11

  KHARAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 14.03.2013 - 15438/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 14.03.2013 - 47215/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 10.04.2012 - 34320/04

  HAKOBYAN AND OTHERS v. ARMENIA
• EGMR, 24.05.2011 - 37193/08

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 19.04.2011 - 49076/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 10.06.2010 - 2220/05

  VAKAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 01.04.2010 - 2952/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 11.02.2010 - 30613/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 24.09.2009 - 33944/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 26.02.2009 - 21080/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 20.12.2007 - 45223/05

  SULTANI c. FRANCE
• EGMR, 25.06.2015 - 25521/10

  SAYDULKHANOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 16.12.2014 - 64969/10

  FIDAN c. TURQUIE
• EGMR, 17.04.2012 - 27365/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.06.2011 - 43368/04

  ISAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 07.06.2011 - 28566/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 10.02.2011 - 1572/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 16.12.2010 - 9960/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 25.11.2010 - 17321/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 15.07.2010 - 20216/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 37542/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 03.11.2009 - 23693/03

  BOJOLYAN v. ARMENIA
• EGMR, 17.09.2009 - 15569/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 23.07.2009 - 24297/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 16.07.2009 - 29851/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 14.05.2009 - 8413/02

  ALIBEKOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 02.04.2009 - 41498/04

  SAYDALIYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 12.02.2009 - 27248/03

  MESHAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 22.01.2009 - 38693/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.01.2009 - 27251/03

  SHAKHGIRIYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 18.12.2008 - 5285/04

  NASUKHANOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 04.12.2008 - 14800/04

  GANDALOYEVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 03.06.2008 - 45653/99

  ANDREOU v. TURKEY
• EGMR, 29.05.2008 - 1839/04

  SANGARIYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 08.11.2007 - 25948/05

  KNYAZEV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 10.05.2007 - 19735/02

  ATICI v. TURKEY
• EGMR, 30.04.2015 - 5713/11

  ISLAMOVA c. RUSSIE
• EGMR, 14.11.2013 - 40042/11

  [FRE]
• EGMR, 12.06.2012 - 47354/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 12.06.2012 - 2546/08

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 03.04.2012 - 25548/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.06.2011 - 26595/08

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 07.06.2011 - 27459/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 17.02.2011 - 45081/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 10.02.2011 - 5382/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.12.2010 - 26980/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 02.09.2010 - 272/05

  VLAEVI c. BULGARIE
• EGMR, 22.07.2010 - 20147/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 10.06.2010 - 26966/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 03.06.2010 - 39676/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 20.05.2010 - 3678/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 12.05.2010 - 39685/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 22.04.2010 - 37461/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 37541/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 38570/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 18.02.2010 - 35869/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 17.09.2009 - 35052/04

  ZABIYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 02.07.2009 - 15440/05

  PUKHIGOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 14.05.2009 - 12417/05

  TURLUYEVA AND KHAMIDOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 23.04.2009 - 28148/03

  KHACHUKAYEV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 09.04.2009 - 15439/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 09.04.2009 - 27244/03

  MALSAGOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 26.02.2009 - 27256/03

  ASTAMIROVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 12.02.2009 - 20727/04

  BANTAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 08.01.2009 - 27180/03

  ABDULKADYROVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 04.12.2008 - 20580/04

  TAGIROVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 04.12.2008 - 1200/03

  UMAYEVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 06.11.2008 - 29958/04

  TSUROVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 03.07.2008 - 32059/02

  AKHIYADOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 12.06.2008 - 3019/04

  ELMURZAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 12.06.2008 - 26064/02

  ATABAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 26.07.2007 - 57941/00

  MUSAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 04.02.2020 - 56120/13

  BAYSULTANOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 07.07.2016 - 78514/14

  R.V. c. FRANCE
• EGMR, 21.10.2014 - 36395/06

  TEMIZALP c. TURQUIE
• EGMR, 12.11.2013 - 56566/10

  [FRE]
• EGMR, 03.10.2013 - 22782/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.11.2011 - 20205/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 25.10.2011 - 33251/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 27.09.2011 - 31564/07

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.06.2011 - 29846/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 21.06.2011 - 17879/08

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 29.07.2010 - 14030/03

  SHCHUKIN AND OTHERS v. CYPRUS
• EGMR, 08.07.2010 - 2747/02

  VACHKOVI v. BULGARIA
• EGMR, 12.05.2010 - 9191/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 32968/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 01.10.2009 - 27001/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 09.07.2009 - 5428/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.01.2009 - 43170/04

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 18.09.2008 - 23286/04

  TAKHAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 29.07.2008 - 11830/03

  GHARIBASHVILI v. GEORGIA
• EGMR, 20.03.2008 - 13737/03

  NENKAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 06.12.2007 - 44803/04

  PETROPOULOU-TSAKIRIS v. GREECE
• EGMR, 22.11.2007 - 13566/02

  ASKHAROVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 08.02.2007 - 12712/02

  RUSLAN UMAROV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 30.01.2007 - 29/02

  KAZIM GUNDOGAN c. TURQUIE
• EGMR, 18.01.2007 - 12703/02

  MUSAYEVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 24.10.2006 - 7653/02

  KAPLANOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 02.12.2010 - 15563/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 02.09.2010 - 32476/06

  Y.P. ET L.P. c. FRANCE
• EGMR, 22.07.2010 - 8347/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 22.04.2010 - 43418/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 33105/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 12.03.2009 - 27238/03

  DZHAMBEKOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 05.02.2009 - 41515/04

  IDALOVA AND IDALOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 15.01.2009 - 35080/04

  ABDURZAKOVA AND ABDURZAKOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 04.12.2008 - 3026/03

  AKHMADOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 23.10.2008 - 8979/02

  MAGOMED MUSAYEV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 09.10.2008 - 13569/02

  ZULPA AKHMATOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 25.09.2008 - 67326/01

  MEZHIDOV v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 29.05.2008 - 1755/04

  GEKHAYEVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 03.03.2011 - 33488/04

  KHAMBULATOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 07.10.2010 - 27315/06

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 08.04.2010 - 8345/05

  [ENG]
• EGMR, 24.09.2009 - 12457/05

  REZVANOV AND REZVANOVA v. RUSSIA
• EGMR, 10.01.2008 - 13670/03

  ARZU AKHMADOVA AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA